Latest Issue: 25 October 2014
25 October 2014
Digital/PDF Version
Previous Issues
Tablet Subscription
Weekly E-Newsletter
Please complete the form correctly!
Tablet Lecture 2014
Tablet Lecture 2014
The Tablet archive
The Tablet archive

Letters Extra

The absence of balance: the environmental lobby, poverty and malaria
03 July 2014

One can only hope for a positive outcome in the trials of the GM Anopheles mosquito described by John Kitui (The Tablet, 28 June) as a path for eliminating the human toll from malaria.

Quite by coincidence Malaysia has recently confirmed the release of 6,000 GM Aedes aegyptii mosquitos directed against dengue fever. John Kitui believes it will be some time before GM mosquito campaign can really get going, even though about half a million children under the age of five are still dying each year still from a disease we failed to control 40 years ago. We failed to eliminate it because of the premature and ill-founded ban on DDT, a substance thought to have saved the lives of two billion people and which didn’t kill anybody. The 1968 statement by Paul Ehrlich, a well-known environmentalist, that “every life saved this year in a poor country diminishes the quality of life for subsequent generations”, adds a more sinister dimension to the background for the ban.

The limited form of thought responsible for the DDT ban is still in evidence today in the opposition of environmentalist groups to the use of Golden Rice, a GM crop designed to prevent Vitamin A deficiency related deaths. Here the toll is put at two million children a year. The Green Revolution of Norman Borlaug gave the lie to the claims in Ehrlich’s Population Bomb. Our vastly increased food supply does not come without some cost, but the naïve projection of the rural idyll in Transylvania (The Tablet, 28 June) typically overlooks the positive. Given the experience of other populations that have been put into eco-zoos the Transylvanians should act quickly.

Dr Michael Hughes, Newbury



Display by
Comments (1)

To post a comment, please log in or register. Registration is quick, easy and free and will enable you to add comments more quickly in future.

Comment by: JohnM
Posted: 25/07/2014 13:00:38

Surely the earth is a finite resource, whether finite today, or tomorrow? Advances in agricultural technology increasing food availability today simply put off the day when food will become insufficient, and pass the problem on to future generations. The proper way to deal with such a problem must surely be prudent population control?