Blogs > Stop scapegoating Muslims: social disaffection has many causes, and they won’t be solved by blunt Government intervention

22 August 2014 | by Francis Davis

Stop scapegoating Muslims: social disaffection has many causes, and they won’t be solved by blunt Government intervention

The lead story in today’s Times – “Hundreds more UK Muslims choose jihad than army” - should provoke grave concern for its inference that Muslim Britons are disloyal subjects, and tend towards extremism. It links international conflicts directly to the domestic terrain, pointing to the 1500 or more young people from our country now fighting abroad for 'Jihadi' causes. In tone it reflects the increasing zeal with which UK policy makers are starting to reach for US neo-conservative narratives of analysis in the Middle East and applying them to a hugely different European situation. For Catholics it will bring back memories of English parishes being raided by the police simply for having high Irish numbers, and parliamentary speeches where Birmingham women with strange headdresses – otherwise known as nuns – were accused of 'being a foreign threat to our children'.

Muslims aren’t the only ones putting people at risk. Hate crime is up in the UK against people with learning disabilities. Domestic violence is up on Saturday nights in those cities where the home teams lose a football match. Last year there were 20,725 rapes in England and Wales and a further 43,475 sexual offences. Alongside 198,176 drug offences there were 4,843 crimes involving a firearm being used. At stake here is the urgent need to defeat the domestic consequences that might flow from frenzied fear of a tiny minority.

Baroness (Pauline) Neville-Jones was one of those who disastrously handled Serbian persecution of Muslims in the nineties but was back on BBC Radio 4 yesterday calling for a more aggressive policy response on the home front. Theresa May leans in the same direction as did Tony Blair, Ruth Kelly and Hazel Blears before her. The trouble though is that from the Northern Ireland to South Africa, Jerusalem to Nicaragua and beyond, state-led community interventions to identify 'moderate' radicals, or to identify potential agents of political violence in advance have more often than not had a radicalising rather than a moderating impact because of their very bluntness and over emphasis on ideology over evidence. For when one reaches for the facts through the rhetoric, the primary threat to our domestic security today seems not to be the Times’ target of a few hundred Muslims abroad, but a deep and dangerous disaffection across whole swathes of our young men.

Francis Davis is a former ministerial adviser on communities, a graduate of the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London and author of several books on the political economy of religion

Share this story

Article List

Post a Comment

You can post as a subscriber user ...

User Comments (5)

Comment by: Francis Davis
Posted: 28/08/2014 10:43:01

Thanks 4 the feedback irrational though it is: ISIS are the UNislamic state + calling them 'the caliphate' too generous. As to violence Im not sure Christianity has such a gd record when it comes to its violent minorities - look at the apartheid state or Swiss Catholic volunteering for extremist Croat regiments. Lets do facts shall we.

Comment by: Jim McCrea
Posted: 27/08/2014 20:43:32

golightly: do you realize how many Christian denominations consider Roman Catholicism to be a cult, the spawn of Satan, etc.?

If you don't think that Catholic Christianity has a sordid history of violence, then your education is sorely lacking.

Comment by: golightly
Posted: 24/08/2014 06:10:55

I don't think anyone is scapegoating muslims, they do it themselves.I don't consider Islam a religion, it's a cult.
From it's very inception Islam has been violent. Mohammed spread, propagated his doctrine with violence. With the Koran in one hand and the sword in the other. One had to choose.
People who have any sympathy for that sort of cult must be wilfully blind like Mr Davis.

Comment by: Denis
Posted: 23/08/2014 15:56:25

It is always wrong to impose blame in a blanket fashion, but at the same time we need to do what Pope Francis has done and call a spade a spade. There are profoundly evil people who call themselves Muslim and who recruit from the lonely, often idle and disaffected and give their lives meaning through hatred. They need to be condemned in vey direct terms.

Comment by: FlosCarmeli
Posted: 23/08/2014 15:35:17

What utter tosh! Muslims are not scapegoated - they bear their own sins not those imposed on them by others. From the UK to Nigeria, Iraq, Syria, and the Sudan the problem is not falsely blaming Islam but it IS Islam or people who claim to represent it. Only Muslims can solve this by definitively showing what they are for and what they are against. For now, let's just work out together how to destroy the Caliphate!


Sign up for our newsletter

Sign Up

Latest Issue
Digital/PDF Version

PDF version (iPad-friendly)

Previous Issues
Tablet Subscription

Manage my subcription here