From the editor's desk From the editor's desk > State of denial

27 February 2014

State of denial

Share this story   

In his apostolic exhortation Evangelii Gaudium, Pope Francis offered the pastors of the Catholic Church guidance on how to interpret traditional teaching concerning marriage and family life. One principle was that “the Church has rules or precepts which may have been quite effective in their time, but no longer have the same usefulness for directing and shaping people’s lives”. Another was that “the Eucharist, although it is the fullness of sacramental life, is not a prize for the perfect but a powerful medicine and nourishment for the weak”. These words are particularly relevant to two of the most contentious issues raised in the recent consultation on marriage and family life: contraception, and the admission of divorced and remarried Catholics to Holy Communion.

These principles, the Pope went on, “have pastoral consequences that we are called to consider with prudence and boldness”. It is plain that bishops’ conferences such as those in Germany and Austria have thoroughly absorbed this wise advice, whose spirit runs right through their official reports on the consultation in their countries. It may still be hoped that the same spirit would inspire whatever opinions the bishops of England and Wales eventually prepare. But if they follow the line taken in the official reflection of Westminster Diocese, the outcome will be a major disappointment. The reflection, published in the diocesan newspaper, falls short of the pastoral sensitivity of the Pope’s words.

Instead it reveals a state of denial that any fundamental problem exists in the gap between Catholic teaching and Catholic practice – except in its implication that all the Church has to do is to re-educate an ignorant and disobedient laity and bring it into line. Yet the Pope himself, in a “letter to families” published this week, humbly seeks to be allowed into every Catholic home to ask for prayers for a satisfactory outcome to this process. “May we all, then, pray together,” he says, “so that through these events the Church will undertake a true journey of discernment ...”

The Westminster reflection is signed by Edmund Adamus, director for marriage and family life, who said it was commissioned and approved by Cardinal Vincent Nichols. “Matters of conscience”, Mr Adamus writes, “centre upon the issues of responsible parenthood and the regulation of fertility. Formation of the moral conscience, therefore, demands fresh efforts on many levels.” And then he says: “The whole of the parish community, including schools, in partnership with parents, must be actively involved in seeking to inspire the young from an early age to aspire to lifelong matrimonial commitment in a loving and stable union open to life.”

Those last three words hardly do justice to those thousands of respondents who, after prayerful discernment, find official Catholic teaching on contraception – that sexual intercourse must always and invariably be “open to life” – incomprehensible or just plain wrong. It becomes all the more imperative, therefore, that the English and Welsh summary of responses should be published in full as soon as possible.



Share this story

Article List




Latest Issue
Digital/PDF Version

PDF version (iPad-friendly)

Previous Issues
Most Read Articles

Organ petition to Cardinal Sarah close to 10,000 signatures15 January 2018 by Megan Cornwell

Vatican adviser says Catholics must take seriously the biblical promises to Israel13 January 2018 by Christopher Lamb in Rome

Papal award for pro-abortion politician 'down to protocol'16 January 2018 by Christopher Lamb

Organ petition to Cardinal Sarah close to 10,000 signatures15 January 2018 by Megan Cornwell

Vatican adviser says Catholics must take seriously the biblical promises to Israel13 January 2018 by Christopher Lamb in Rome

Papal award for pro-abortion politician 'down to protocol'16 January 2018 by Christopher Lamb

‘I had never heard silence so solid’: a palliative care specialist reflects on lessons learnt from listening to the dyingPremium10 January 2018 by Kathryn Mannix

The Word made fresh: translating the New TestamentPremium10 January 2018 by David Bentley Hart

The other Saint George: George Orwell's nuanced and ambivalent views's on ReligionPremium10 January 2018 by D.J. Taylor

‘I had never heard silence so solid’: a palliative care specialist reflects on lessons learnt from listening to the dyingPremium10 January 2018 by Kathryn Mannix

The Word made fresh: translating the New TestamentPremium10 January 2018 by David Bentley Hart

The other Saint George: George Orwell's nuanced and ambivalent views's on ReligionPremium10 January 2018 by D.J. Taylor

Organ petition to Cardinal Sarah close to 10,000 signatures15 January 2018 by Megan Cornwell

Vatican adviser says Catholics must take seriously the biblical promises to Israel13 January 2018 by Christopher Lamb in Rome

Papal award for pro-abortion politician 'down to protocol'16 January 2018 by Christopher Lamb

‘I had never heard silence so solid’: a palliative care specialist reflects on lessons learnt from listening to the dyingPremium10 January 2018 by Kathryn Mannix

The Word made fresh: translating the New TestamentPremium10 January 2018 by David Bentley Hart

The other Saint George: George Orwell's nuanced and ambivalent views's on ReligionPremium10 January 2018 by D.J. Taylor

Tablet Subscription

Manage my subcription here

Manage
Top