Letters

Separate tables; American tragedy; Cardinal dissenters; Jesuit diet; Signs and wonders; Church closure; Richard the baptist Premium

08 December 2016

 

Separate tables
Sue Oakley (Letters, 3 December) argues that interchurch couples should take responsibility for their own actions rather than seek formal approval for sharing Communion, as required by the hierarchy of England and Wales.

Back in the 1990s, my Anglican wife and I knew another interchurch couple who made frequent day trips to Boulogne, where they could receive the Catholic Eucharist without any formal request, because of the different norms adopted by the French hierarchy. In 1999, when we wished to celebrate our silver wedding anniversary, I asked our archbishop, who I knew quite well, for a one-off permission. He rejected my request, as the rules stated that it must be routed via the parish priest. Although we eventually received permission, the whole rigmarole was so tiresome that we have never since repeated the request.

Though my wife and I are quite “capable of carrying out our own discernment”, we know that this is a dangerous thing to do in a parish where one is well known. There is often a minority of lay people ready to report such discernment to the church authorities. This can cause personal grief and also embarrassment to parish clergy. Just the other day I heard of an interchurch family where the Catholic father-in-law had stopped his Anglican son-in-law from receiving the Catholic Eucharist. What a shocking contrast from the lovely priest who once said to me, “Who am I to deny the Body of Christ to anyone?”

Tony Hadland
Faringdon, Oxfordshire





Subscribe now and enjoy access to all parts of the tablet website, Including its 175 year archive...
Subscribe


Article List


TABLET WORLD…
Latest Issue

Digital/PDF Version

PDF version (iPad-friendly)

Previous Issues
Latest Tweet
Most Read Articles

German bishops abandon controversial Missal translation09 October 2017 by Christa Pongratz-Lippitt

German bishops abandon controversial Missal translation09 October 2017 by Christa Pongratz-Lippitt

Change Catholic teaching to make death penalty 'inadmissible', says Pope12 October 2017 by Christopher Lamb

Change Catholic teaching to make death penalty 'inadmissible', says Pope12 October 2017 by Christopher Lamb

Pro Francis theologians start petition in support of Pope following 'filial correction' 18 October 2017 by Christopher Lamb

Pro Francis theologians start petition in support of Pope following 'filial correction' 18 October 2017 by Christopher Lamb

Martin Luther’s new religion: Luther’s teaching on justification by faith alone demanded a complete reshaping of ChristianityPremium11 October 2017 by Richard Rex

Changing minds and hearts: the basic moral test of a society and its laws is the treatment of human life at its most vulnerablePremium18 October 2017 by John Wilson

Royal escape: historian and uncle to Princes William and Harry, Charles SpencerPremium11 October 2017 by Joanna Moorhead

Martin Luther’s new religion: Luther’s teaching on justification by faith alone demanded a complete reshaping of ChristianityPremium11 October 2017 by Richard Rex

Changing minds and hearts: the basic moral test of a society and its laws is the treatment of human life at its most vulnerablePremium18 October 2017 by John Wilson

Royal escape: historian and uncle to Princes William and Harry, Charles SpencerPremium11 October 2017 by Joanna Moorhead

Share Us
Tablet Subscription

Manage my subcription here

Manage
Newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign Up
Top