02 August 2018, The Tablet

US bishop names 71 priests, dead and alive, accused of abuse

by CNS

Bishop Gainer also ordered the names of former diocesan bishops removed from buildings, halls and rooms

 US bishop names 71 priests, dead and alive, accused of abuse

Bishop Ronald W. Gainer of Harrisburg, Pa., released a list of the names of 71 clergy, both dead and alive, accused of abuse
Photo: Photo: CNS/Robert Duncan

A United States bishop has released a list of the names of 71 clergy, both dead and alive, accused of abuse.

The Bishop of Harrisburg Bishop Ronald W. Gainer released the information from the diocese's own internal investigation on child sex abuse, and also ordered removal from buildings, halls and rooms the names of former diocesan bishops going back to 1947.

The name ban extends to anyone who appears on the diocese's list and has been accused of sexual misconduct, and also to any position of honor in the diocese given those named.

"It is my most unwelcome, yet necessary, duty to visit a sorry chapter of the Diocese of Harrisburg's history, the one concerning the sexual abuse of minors," said Bishop Gainer in an open letter.

"As has been the subject of much public discussion, the diocese has unfortunately at times been the home of men originally called to the service of God who, for reasons unknown and unfathomable, instead ignored that summons and turned to the pursuit of heinous personal ends."

Bishop Gainer, whose diocese is in Pennsylvania, continued: "That conduct has left a legacy of pain and sorrow that is still being felt. On behalf of the Diocese of Harrisburg, I apologise for these actions."

While these harms of the past "cannot be undone," he said, "it is my hope that today I can do my part as the present chief shepherd of the diocese to salve some of these historic wounds with the healing touch of transparency."

To that end, he released a detailed list giving the names of 71 clergy and seminarians credibly accused of abuse, with a description of the alleged abuse, ranging from indecent behavior to inappropriate "communication with children". As he said, the information is not an assessment of guilt but provides historic details of the accusations.

Among those named are vowed religious who served in the diocese and diocesan priests accused of misconduct in another diocese.

As a result of a review of historical cases, conducted by professional investigators and outside counsel, "it was also clear that the leadership of the church did not in every case take adequate measures when handling matters related to offending clerics," the diocese said in a statement.

The bishop's release of pages of detailed information – which is being described as unprecedented – comes ahead of the expected release of a redacted version of a grand jury report based on a months-long investigation by the state's attorney general into sexual abuse claims in six Pennsylvania dioceses. Many of the claims go back decades.

Besides Harrisburg, the dioceses are Pittsburgh, Allentown, Scranton, Erie and Greensburg.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled July 27 the redacted report should be released. In June, the court had put a hold on the full report being released because it said it needed to review challenges filed by "many individuals" named in the report.

"A number of the petitioners asserted that they were not aware of, or allowed to appear at, the proceedings before the grand jury," the court said in its earlier opinion.

In its new ruling, the court said the report will be edited to protect the identities of those challenging its release and the redacted version can be made available to the public as early as Aug. 8 and no later than Aug. 14.

"While this list cannot undo what which has been done, it is my sincere hope that it can in some way bring relief to those who have unfortunately been harmed throughout our history," said Bishop Gainer.

"In the meantime, the diocese will remain steadfast in its efforts to ensure that this chapter never repeats. I also recommit myself, my staff, all clergy, and every man and woman associated with the diocese to eradicate abuse in our midst."

The diocese had intended on releasing its list of accused abusers nearly two years ago, but the state attorney general's office had asked the diocese to not do so to protect its own investigation.

Bishop Gainer also waived any confidentiality provision in a settlement made by the diocese with an abuse victim. "Though it has been the diocese's policy for some time not to enforce those confidentiality provisions, Bishop Gainer learned that some survivors still feel constrained by them," said an Aug. 1 statement by the diocese.

"The survivors can feel free to tell their stories to whomever and whenever they wish," said Bishop Gainer. "I hope that this step will further aid those survivors, and perhaps others, in their path to healing."

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99