24 July 2017, The Tablet

Chinese official indicates Beijing to retain tight grip on church

Vatican regards the patriotic association as incompatible with church doctrine, because its constitution advocates an independent church

Chinese official indicates Beijing to retain tight grip on church

The Chinese Communist Party's top leader in charge of religion has made it clear that Beijing intends to retain a tight grip on the Catholic Church.

Yu Zhengsheng, a member of the elite seven-man Politburo Standing Committee and chair of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference, told members of the open church community "to ensure that the leadership of the Chinese Catholic Church is held firmly in the hands of those who love the nation and the religion," reported ucanews.com.

Yu spoke to about 100 bishops, priests, nuns and lay leaders at the Great Hall of the People in Beijing on 19 July at an event commemorating the 60th anniversary of the state-controlled Chinese Catholic Patriotic Association. He made his comments amid continuing talks between Beijing and the Vatican about the normalisation of the appointment of bishops, the first step in a path that could lead to the establishment of diplomatic relations.

But negotiations appear to have slowed in recent months due to an impasse over the fate of a handful of Beijing-appointed bishops.

During his speech, Yu also encouraged church leaders to "implement with self-awareness the basic direction of religious works," and "always to insist on the direction of Sinicization of religion."

The main event was preceded by a ceremony presided over by Wang Zuoan, director of the State Administration for Religious Affairs. Wang affirmed the results of the patriotic association over the past 60 years, noting that the organization has walked the path of adaptation to a socialist society and the principles of independence and self-management, ucanews.com reported.

The patriotic association was established on 2 August, 1957, by the National Congress of Catholic Representatives, which also stands above the bishops' conference, an organisation that also answers to Beijing, not the Vatican. The government claimed the patriotic association is a "bridge" between the church and the government.

The Vatican does not recognise all three national church bodies and regards the patriotic association as being incompatible with church doctrine, because its constitution advocates the principle of an independent church.

The establishment of the patriotic association also split China's 10 million Catholics. Following the Vatican's stance, the so-called underground church community rejected the organisation, and many clergy and laypeople suffered for this. Ucanews.com reported many laypeople despise the patriotic association for its control of the church and alleged misuse of church property.

But the division is far from black and white: Many clergy in the so-called open church community show resistance to the patriotic association but believe collaboration offers space for church development. In the 19 July ceremony, some Vatican-approved bishops did not wear their bishops' garb, as a subtle way to show that the meeting was not a church event.

Father Shanren, a pen name of a Chinese priest-commentator, pointed out that the ceremony was held in a low-profile manner without using the word "celebration" but "commemoration," possibly because of the delicate state of China-Vatican relations, ucanews.com reported.

PICTURE: People are seen at the Tiananmen Gate in Beijing on 14 July. A Chinese communist party official indicated on 19 July that Beijing intends to retain tight grip on the Catholic Church

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99