03 April 2014, The Tablet

Hierarchy rejects call to refuse politicians Communion

The BISHOPS’ Conference of England and Wales has told Catholic parliamentarians that they will not be refused Communion if they voted in favour of same-sex marriage.

This move follows comments last month by the Bishop of Portsmouth, Philip Egan, who said that these politicians should be denied the Eucharist. He argued that instead of being a punitive measure it was “an act of mercy” that could bring individuals “back into communion with the Church”.

But an email from the bishops’ conference sent last month to parliamentarians, and seen by The Tablet, said: “There are no plans by any bishops in England and Wales to deny Communion to Catholic MPs or peers who voted in favour of same-sex marriage legislation last year.”

The email was authorised by the bishops’ conference, whose presi­dent is the Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster, Vincent Nichols. A spokesman for the bishops said: “This was done with the approval of the general secretary after appropriate consultation.”

When he made the remarks about refusing politicians Communion, Bishop Egan said he would need to act with his fellow bishops and he called on his confrères to debate the issue. But a bishops’ spokesman said there are “no plans” to discuss the matter at their next biannual meeting due to take place soon after Easter.

The email, written by Greg Pope, the head of parliamentary relations for the bishops’ conference and a former Labour MP, added: “I can see that there is potential for distress to be caused within the Catholic community at Westminster over this.” Catholic MPs across the political spectrum have reacted with anger to Bishop Egan’s call. These include Conor Burns, a Conservative MP who voted for same-sex marriage and whose Bournemouth West seat lies in the bishop’s Portsmouth diocese. Mr Burns, who is co-chairman of the All Party Parliamentary Group on the Holy See, says he now feels unable to receive Communion in his local parish. It is understood that he has written to Cardinal Nichols requesting a meeting to discuss the matter.

Forty-seven out of at least 82 Catholic MPs voted for same-sex marriage legislation, which was passed last year. These included Conservative Cabinet ministers Iain Duncan Smith and Patrick McLoughlin. Bishop Egan made his initial comments in an interview with a pro-life website, LifeSiteNews. He said: “When people are not in communion with the Catholic Church on such a central thing as the value of the unborn child, and also in terms of the teachings of the Church on marriage and family life – they are voting in favour of same-sex ­marriage – then they shouldn’t be receiving Holy Communion.”

A spokesman for Bishop Egan said the bishop had nothing further to add to his earlier comments.

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99