03 March 2016, The Tablet

Cardinal Pell admits he knew about Catholic abuse complaint and failed to act

On the fourth and final day of the inquiry the cardinal has admitted he was told about one Christian Brother

Cardinal George Pell has concluded his evidence to Australia’s abuse commission with an admission that he was informed of an abuse complaint but didn’t act on it. 

Back in the 1970s the cardinal said that a schoolboy came to him about Edward Dowlan, a Christian Brother who was later convicted of abusing at least 20 boys. The cardinal said: “He just mentioned it casually in conversation, he never asked me to do anything.”

After being asked by the commission’s lawyer why he didn’t take the allegation to the school Pell said: “People had a different attitude then. There was no specifics about the activity, how serious it was and the boy wasn’t asking me to do anything about it but just lamenting and mentioning it.”

The cardinal, who is Prefect of the Secretariat for the Economy of the Holy See, has been giving evidence this week to the commission via video-link at the Albergo Quirinale in Rome

During a final, gruelling day of questioning, which saw the cardinal cross-examined by lawyers for victims, the 74-year-old churchman also said he defied opposition in Rome to remove abusive priest Peter Searson from a parish when he was Archbishop of Melbourne.  

"I was quite clear in my obligations to the community so I must say I just ignored the Roman decision and Rome didn't push the point,” he said. 

But the commission, which is examining institutional responses into clerical sexual abuse, also heard that as an auxiliary Bishop of Melbourne he received complaints about Searson but left the matter to the Catholic education office. Searson died before he could be prosecuted for interfering with young girls during confession and for child sex abuse.

During the four days of questioning, Pell has been asked about his knowledge of abuse in the 1970s and 80s, particularly in his home Diocese of Ballarat which had a number of abusive priests. 

One of them was Gerald Ridsdale who was convicted of abusing 54 children and whom Pell once shared a presbytery with. 

The cardinal angered victims on Tuesday by saying that he wasn’t “much interested” in the case of Ridsdale but last night said he regretted his choice of words. 

He also denied a claim that he tried to silence David Ridsdale, who was abused by his uncle Gerald. David claims in a telephone call in 1993 he told Pell – a friend of the family – of the abuse by his uncle. David alleges that during the phone call the cardinal asked him what could be done to “keep him quiet”.

David Ridsdale is among a number of abuse victims who had travelled to Rome to hear Pell’s evidence. They have, however, criticised his testimony describing it as “performance”. At a brief press conference last night the cardinal said he hoped his appearance at the commission – which was voluntary – would bring about some healing.

Pell met today in Rome with a dozen survivors of abuse from his home town of Ballarat in what he described afterwards as a "hard, honest and occasionally emotional meeting".
He added: "I know many of their families and I know the goodness of so many people in Catholic Ballarat."
Following the encounter the cardinal pledged himself to trying to support victims particularly trying to prevent the suicide of those who have been abused. He said he wanted to help make Ballarat a place of healing and peace and hoped it could become a centre of practical help for those wounded by abuse. 
One of the survivors, Phil Nagle, described the meeting as positive and said it focussed on the future not the past.  "I think he gets it," Mr Nagle added. 
The victims, who leave Rome tomorrow, are also hopeful for a meeting with Pope Francis.   

The cardinal said he had ensured that Pope Francis and the Vatican’s Secretary of State had been kept informed of developments at the commission.


Follow all the latest news and events from the Catholic world via The Tablet's Twitter feed @the_tablet

Or you can join in the debate at our community page on Facebook

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99