19 October 2023, The Tablet

Jerusalem patriarchs condemn ‘massacre’ at Gaza hospital

by Marinella Bandini, CNA

Bishop Hosam Naum said the Anglican-run Al Ahli Hospital was internationally recognised as a reliable neutral institution.


Jerusalem patriarchs condemn ‘massacre’ at Gaza hospital

Bishop Hosam Naum of the Episcopal Diocese of Jerusalem, third from right, between Greek Orthodox Patriarch Theophilus III and the Latin Patriarch Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa, at the Wednesday press conference.
Marinella Brandini / CNA

The Patriarchs and Heads of the Churches in Jerusalem issued a statement and convened a press conference on Wednesday to condemn the “criminal attack” on the Al Ahli Hospital.

On the evening of Tuesday 17 October, the day Christian communities in the Holy Land had dedicated to prayer and fasting for peace, an explosion at the Anglican-run hospital in Gaza killed hundreds of civilians.

The bombing shocked communities who had prayed throughout the day and ignited anger throughout the Middle East and across the world. 

Approximately 500 people lost their lives in the explosion, according to the Palestinian Ministry of Health. As a hospital, the location was supposed to be protected by international law, and hundreds of people had found refuge there over the past week. 

Immediately, the Episcopal Diocese of Jerusalem, led by Bishop Hosam Naum, issued a statement condemning this “atrocious attack” in the heart of Gaza, where the hospital has been providing protection and care to the population for more than 120 years and is internationally recognised as a reliable and super partes (neutral) institution.

The diocese called for unanimous international condemnation and for the international community to commit to protecting civilians and ensuring that such “inhumane horrific acts” are not repeated.

The Patriarchs and Heads of the Churches jointly appealed “for justice, peace, and the cessation of the suffering that has descended upon the people of Gaza”, a message voiced by Bishop Naum at the press conference in Jerusalem.

“We stand together in condemning this dreadful and devastating massacre, and we regard it as a crime against humanity. A sanctuary, a place that was meant to be a place of prayer, and a place of healing, turned into the scene of a very horrific massacre for our people in Gaza,” he said. 

Only shortly before, the bishop said, “people who are civilians who were gathered in the courtyard were singing for peace and the children were playing. Why did this happen? Why, just two hours later, were they struck down by death?” 

Just two weeks ago, Naum had visited the facility for new projects with the Lutheran World Federation, after the recent opening of the chemotherapy service.

Three days ago, the hospital was hit by two rockets. One damaged the fourth floor and the roof of the new diagnostic centre. The other hit the ultrasound and mammography room on the second floor. The hospital, the bishop reported, received “three evacuation warnings” from the Israeli side, “on Saturday, Sunday, and Monday”, but yesterday, he said, “I am not aware of any”.

After an initial emergency evacuation, the hospital is back in operation. 

“The hospital will continue to be open,” the bishop emphasised, while also not hiding the difficult situation caused by shortages. “They’re running out of water and supplies.”

“We are determined – not only the Anglican Church, but all the churches – we are determined to keep our institutions open, to keep our places of worship, our churches, open as places of refuge, especially to those who are disadvantaged.”

Naum refused to apportion blame for the explosion. “We are not military people to decide [what happened]. We are not journalists to analyse. We are not politicians to decide [what to do],” he said.

“What we are saying here is that what happened in the hospital is a crime. Let there be an end to the violence and let there be a just and lasting peace.” 

The bishop consistently reiterated the message: “As heads of the churches, we have said very clearly that we are against any violence against any civilians or innocent people on any side of the divide.

“Let people see what is happening, even beyond the hospital, and they will draw the conclusion that enough with this war, enough with these lives that have been lost on both sides.”

Wednesday also saw US President Joe Biden arrive in Tel Aviv, where he reiterated full support for Israel but also said that the solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict must be the two-state solution.

“What I expect from President Biden and every world leader,” Naum said, “is that they stand for peace and justice in this land, to end the conflict, in accordance with UN resolutions and international law. We want them to be a voice for peace and reconciliation, for the sake of everybody – Israelis and Palestinians.” 

He also confirmed that all the churches of the Holy Land to face every challenge together and to share every step. 


  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99