13 July 2023, The Tablet

Cupich urges German Church to overcome divisions


“We must listen to one another and respect one another but we must also listen to the voice of Catholic tradition.”


Cupich urges German Church to overcome divisions

Cardinal Blase Cupich is considered an ally of Pope Francis among the US bishops.
Daniel Ibanez / CNA

In an interview with the Archdiocese of Cologne’s domradio.de, the Archbishop of Chicago, Cardinal Blase Cupich, emphasised the importance of ending polarisation and overcoming entrenched divisions in the Church and the world.

“It is important that we should not only try and win an argument and to convince the other side of our arguments,” he said.

“We must find ways to bridge the divisions between us which polarisation has ripped open both in the world and the Church. We must listen to one another and respect one another but we must also listen to the voice of Catholic tradition.”

Regarding the German synodal path initiative, Cupich said he was not acquainted with the details but pointed out that if it was a “sort of parliamentary procedure in which democratic voting was paramount, where votes are counted and opposing arguments are presented, then from a Catholic point of view that would be difficult to defend”.

He added, however, that he knew a number of German bishops and was confident they had the best of intensions.

“They are good shepherds, who are doing their best to listen to the faithful and to understand their hopes and desires. I think the initiative will come to a good end.”

He said he had reservations about the German initiative’s call for lay Catholics to be able to hold the sermon at Mass but added that he would “have no problem with women or lay Catholics in general holding a reflection at some other point in the Mass – perhaps after communion”.

Cupich also said it was imperative to respect same-sex couples who desired a church blessing.

“But at the same time we must ask ourselves exactly what it means to bless a union. Is it a blessing for a friendship – a non-sacramental union? We must quite clearly define what we mean by this blessing. For the moment, the Church has not yet done that.”

The cardinal also warned against calling the hierarchical structure of the Church into question. As St Peter’s successor the Pope not only guaranteed Church unity but also the Church community’s capacity to survive, he said.

“Whosoever argues against this runs the risk of creating a schism in the Church. It is also against the will of the Holy Spirit whose voice the Pope represents.”

Pope Francis’ pontificate was “historic”, Cupich said.

“Like the pontificate of Pope St John XXIII and the Second Vatican Council, history will look on this period as a turning point in church history. By calling on us to listen to one another and to the Holy Spirit, Francis is leading us into the next chapter of church history”, he said.

“I know there are critical voices – but they are few. They are loud but there aren’t many of them”.


  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99