30 January 2023, The Tablet

L'Arche publishes Vanier abuse report

An independent commission found that Jean Vanier belonged to a “sectarian group” with “distorted pseudo-mystical beliefs”.

L'Arche publishes Vanier abuse report

Jean Vanier, pictured in 2015 after receiving the Templeton Prize.
Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales/Mazur

L’Arche UK has welcomed a report on the abuse carried out by Jean Vanier, the founder of the first L’Arche communities where people with and without learning disabilities live together.

An independent commission set up by L’Arche International found that at least 25 women “experienced sexual contact with Vanier which was part of a continuum of confusion, control and abuse” between 1950 and his death in 2019.

Evidence of abuse by Vanier was first revealed by an inquiry in 2020. The commission’s 900-page report, published on 30 January, finds that he belonged to a “sectarian group” in the L’Arche Trosly community with “distorted pseudo-mystical beliefs and a culture of deliberate secrecy”.

The group was influenced by the “deviant mystic” Thomas Philippe, a Dominican priest who also committed abuse.

In a letter to all members of L’Arche, the heads of the international organisation, Stephan Posner and Stacy Cates-Carney, said that the abuse was “in total contradiction with the elementary rules of respect and integrity of persons, and contrary to the fundamental principles of our communities”.

They continued: “We recognise our institutional responsibility for failing to spot these abuses, report them and forestall them.

“At the same time, we feel that our founder’s adherence to the doctrines of Thomas Philippe and the reproduction of his practices, their concealment and the lies that followed, constitute a serious breach of trust towards L’Arche and its members.”

The commission reports that with the founding of L’Arche in 1963, Vanier entered into “an unexpected dynamic, and embark[ed] on a path of which he did not expect the fruitfulness”.

A “sectarian nucleus” of the community at Trosly subscribed to Philippe’s doctrines, but the “rapid development of the communities and the arrival of numerous people with different profiles and motivations … explain the limited diffusion of the sectarian core”.

However, the report’s authors urge “vigilance” to guard against abuse elsewhere.

None of the 25 women whose abuse is recorded had learning disabilities, nor did the commission find any evidence of abuse of people with learning disabilities.

The abuse described in the report did not take place in the UK, but John Casson, the national leader of L’Arche UK, said that it was “part of our story as members of the worldwide L’Arche family”.

He called the report “a significant step in L’Arche’s commitment to respond with truth, transparency and justice”.

“We condemn Vanier’s grooming, manipulation, abuse and lies, which betray everything we work for in L’Arche every day,” he said.

“We welcome and share L’Arche International’s request for forgiveness that the organisation was not able to identify and stop the abuse. We thank the courageous women who broke decades of silence.”

He emphasised that members of L’Arche communities, “not Jean Vanier, are the ones who represent the mission and the values of L’Arche today”.

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99