22 July 2022, The Tablet

Vatican steps up in challenge to German synodal pathway

by Cindy Wooden, CNS

German Synodal Path must not create new structures, doctrines, Vatican says.

Vatican steps up in challenge to German synodal pathway

A general view from October last year of the second Synodal Assembly in Frankfurt, Germany.
CNS photo/Julia Steinbrecht, KNA.

The Vatican has stepped up to challenge the German synodal pathway, stating that it has no power to create new structures or  doctrines.

An unsigned declaration of the Holy See states: “It seems necessary to make it clear that the synodal path in Germany does not have the power to compel bishops and the faithful to assume new modes of governance and new approaches to doctrine and morals.”  

Released by the Vatican press office in German and Italian yesterday, the declaration says the Catholic Church in Germany could not “initiate new official structures or doctrines in the dioceses prior to an agreed understanding at the level of the universal church”.

Doing so, it says, “would represent a wound to ecclesial communion and a threat to the unity of the church”.

In response, the two presidents of the German Synodal Path insisted: “We never tire of underlining that the church in Germany will not follow a special German path.” They said that the rules of the process have made clear from the beginning that resolutions passed by the Synodal Assembly have no legal effect of their own accord.

But the assembly presidents – Bishop Georg Bätzing, president of the of the German bishops’ conference, and Irme Stetter-Karp, president of the Central Committee of German Catholics – took issue with the tone of the Vatican declaration and particularly with it being unsigned.

“Since the beginning of the Synodal Path, the synodal committee has endeavoured to find direct ways of communication with the Roman bodies,” they said in a statement late July 21. “In our opinion, this would be the right place for such clarifications.

“Unfortunately, the synodal committee has not been invited to a discussion to date. We regret with irritation that this direct communication has not yet taken place. In our understanding, a synodal church is something else!

“This also applies to the way today’s communication has been handled, which has been a source of astonishment for us. It is not a good example of communication within the church if statements are published which are not signed by name.”

While Bishop Bätzing and Stetter-Karp repeated that members of the assembly know they cannot change church teaching or basic church structures, “nevertheless, we see it as our duty to clearly state where we believe changes are necessary. In doing so, we already sense that the problems and questions we have named are similar worldwide,” including as seen in diocesan and national reports prepared as part of the process for the world Synod of Bishops.

The fourth assembly of the synodal path in Germany is scheduled to meet 8 to 10 September in Frankfurt with plans to debate a series of revised texts and vote on them for possible adoption as resolutions of the synodal path.

The assembly is made up of the members of the German bishops’ conference, 69 representatives of the central committee of German Catholics, and other representatives of spiritual ministries and church offices, young people and individuals. In total, the synodal assembly comprises 230 people.

At its meeting in early February, the assembly passed resolutions calling for a greater role and voice for laypeople in church decision making and for the involvement of laypeople in cathedral chapters that have a voice in recommending the names of candidates to be submitted to the pope for possible nomination as bishops.

The assembly also made its initial consideration of motions to encourage a relaxation of the rule of mandatory celibacy for most Latin-rite priests and in favour of the ordination of women as deacons. The blessing of same-sex unions has been widely discussed as well, but not formally adopted by the assembly.

The power of the assembly to make decisions for the Catholic Church in Germany has been widely and repeatedly discussed.

Bishop Georg Bätzing, president of the of the German bishops’ conference, said in an April letter responding to bishops from other countries criticising the German process that all resolutions calling for reforms that can only be implemented at the universal church level would be submitted to the worldwide synodal process. This process, currently underway, was launched by Pope Francis in preparation for the 2023 Synod of Bishops on synodality.

In a 2019 letter to German Catholics, a letter also quoted in the new declaration, Pope Francis emphasised that synodality is a process that must be guided by the Holy Spirit with patience and not a “search for immediate results that generate quick and immediate consequences”. Transformation “calls for pastoral conversion”, he said.

“Brothers and sisters, let us care for one another and be attentive to the temptation of the father of lies and division, the master of separation who, in pushing us to seek an apparent good or a response to a given situation, in fact ends up fragmenting the body of the holy and faithful people of God,” the Pope said.

The July declaration from the Vatican reminds Catholics in Germany of Pope Francis’ words to them in 2019 that the local church and the universal church live and flourish together.

If local churches separate from the whole, he said, “they become debilitated, rot and die. Hence the need to keep communion with the whole body of the church always alive and effective.”

The Vatican declaration says: “it is hoped that the proposals of the path of the particular churches in Germany will flow into the synodal path being taken by the universal church for mutual enrichment and a witness to that unity by which the body of the church manifests its fidelity to Christ the Lord.”

The Catholic Church in Germany launched the Synodal Path on 1 December 2019, in a search for ways to restore trust lost in the clergy abuse scandal. Scheduled to conclude its work by February 2023, it is debating the issues of power, sexual morality, priestly existence and the role of women in the church.

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99