18 September 2020, The Tablet

Cardinal fears schism as 'worst outcome' of reforms

by CNS

Cardinal fears schism as 'worst outcome' of reforms

Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, Archbishop of Cologne, fears possible schism over German church reforms.
Andreas Arnold/DPA/PA Images

The Archbishop of Cologne, Cardinal Rainer Maria Woelki, has warned that the synodal path reform project could lead to a “German national church”.

The cardinal said: “The worst outcome would be if the Synodal Path leads to a schism ... with the universal church.” 

Speaking to Germany’s Catholic News Agency, KNA, he continued: “That would be the worst thing, if something like a German national church were to be created here.”

KNA reported that Cardinal Woelki also praised the most recent discussions within the synodal path, held in five regional conferences due to the coronavirus pandemic. Smaller groups of participants permitted a better exchange of arguments than would have been possible in the originally planned Synodal Assembly, Cardinal Woelki said.

The Catholic Church in Germany launched the synodal path in 2019. Scheduled to run for two years, it is debating the issues of power, sexual morality, priestly existence and the role of women in the church. The aim is to restore trust lost in the clergy abuse scandal.

But the cardinal urged participants to avoid creating “unfulfillable hopes” regarding the ordination of women priests. This would cause frustration, he told KNA, because the issue had been decided by St John Paul II.

“I cannot treat it as if the question were open,” the cardinal said. “In that case, the discussion takes place outside the teaching of the church.”

As Pope, in 1994, St John Paul II reaffirmed that the church does not have the authority to confer priestly ordination on women and declared that this teaching is to be definitively held by all the faithful.

Cardinal Woelki criticised the theological standard of some of the working papers prepared for the synodal path. He said: “The whole world is looking at the church in Germany and at this synodal path right now, so we can't just permit ourselves to embarrass ourselves theologically through ineptitude.”

He urged theologians in and outside the synodal path talks to become more involved in the debate.

Cardinal Woelki also expressed the hope that the process would succeed in “initiating a true reform, which is definitely needed in the church”.

This reform, he said, must “correct all manifestations and realities that have led away from the nature of the church”. It was about understanding the church not as a “purely sociological entity” but rather about understanding “that it is the work of God”. The goal of any reform of the church must be to move toward Christ and his message, he said.

Many Catholics no longer knew “who Christ is, what the church is, they no longer know what a sacrament is, what the sacramental structure of the church is”, the cardinal said.

The Catholic weekly newspaper Die Tagespost reported Sept. 17 that 53 per cent of German Catholics said they were not interested in the synodal path. The lack of interest among Germans as a whole was greater at 63 per cent, with 11 per cent saying they were interested and 17 per cent undecided.

More than 2,000 adults were interviewed for the survey from Sept. 11-14.

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99