19 May 2020, The Tablet

Top psychiatrist criticises failure on public worship



Top psychiatrist criticises failure on public worship

Professor Patricia Casey
Brian Lawless/PA Archive/PA Images

One of Ireland’s leading psychiatrists has criticised the Irish bishops over their failure to lobby the Government more actively to restore public worship sooner than 20 July.

Writing in the Irish Independent this week, Professor Patricia Casey, a consultant psychiatrist in the Mater Hospital in Dublin and Emeritus Professor of Psychiatry at UCD, said the lockdown has been a huge spiritual sacrifice, in the interests of the common good. “This makes the resumption of public services a significant event for Christians of all denominations and for other faiths.”

Restrictions on public worship due to the Covid-19 pandemic have been in place since 23 March, although many churches in the Republic remain open for private prayer. In Northern Ireland churches are completely closed on the instruction of the UK government.

Under the Irish Government’s exit strategy from lockdown, Sunday Masses will resume on 20 July, with restricted numbers, in the fourth of the Government’s five stage road map for the reopening of the country.

“But it is more than two months from now,” Professor Casey criticised and noted that none of the bishops, apart from Bishop Kevin Doran, “has uttered any discontent on behalf of the faithful in Ireland”.

Referring to last week’s online meeting between the Taoiseach Leo Varadkar and three Archbishops, Professor Casey criticised the lack of information about what was discussed. 

A patron of the conservative Iona Institute, Dr Casey said members of the laity, like her, have questions for the bishops including “Who asked for the meeting? Was an earlier resumption of services such as Sunday Mass discussed?”

“The bishops should advocate for the spiritual welfare of the people in the pews. They should not be sounding like Department of Health bureaucrats. Their passivity does not attract admiration but rather disrespectful glee from those actively hostile to religion,” she said in her article.

Meanwhile, Archbishop Diarmuid Martin has told priests in his diocese to prepare a detailed plan for their parishes so that they will be ready when restrictions on public worship begin to ease.

One of the recommendations is that Eucharistic Ministers will have to wear facemasks and disposable gloves when distributing Holy Communion.

Speaking to RTE Radio’s ‘Today with Sarah McInerney’ last week, Archbishop Martin warned that the scale of the, “reopening of churches for worship has serious public health concerns and we have to make sure that we are ready for them.”

He highlighted that on an ordinary Sunday before the Covid-19 restrictions about 200,000 people attended Mass in Ireland’s largest diocese. “That is a huge movement of population.”

He stressed that parishes must ensure that anybody who comes to Mass when the restrictions are lifted feels safe in church. On the necessity for reduced congregations to ensure social distancing, the Archbishop of Dublin said one way to deal with this would be to remove the Sunday obligation so that people could go to Mass any day during the week.

 


  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99