30 August 2019, The Tablet

Bishop condemns fake 'mystic rose' miracles

by CNS

Roses are indeed beautiful, but on this occasion they were most definitely not miraculous flowerings of the Virgin

Bishop condemns fake 'mystic rose' miracles

Mary was said to have left the miraculous gift of a rose. But did she?
Ruth Gledhill

A bishop has condemned apparent messages and miracles of the Virgin Mary as fake.

In a letter to local Catholics, Bishop of Fort Worth Michael F Olson said recent "purported apparitions, messages and miracles" of Mary that he had cautioned Catholics about weeks before "are, in fact, a fabrication".

The bishop said the diocese had received "irrefutable evidence" showing that reported Marian appearances and messages from St Mark's Church in Argyle under the title "Mystical Rose – Our Lady of Argyle" are not true.

He said diocesan officials examined security camera footage that shows "the alleged visionary surreptitiously dropping a rose on the floor of a room" but later claiming the rose was a "miraculous gift of the Virgin Mary".

The footage was provided by Loreto House, a pro-life assistance centre in Denton, where the alleged mystic and others who are part of a self-described "Dry Bones Ministry" had attended eucharistic adoration July 27 and claimed to experience another apparition.

At Bishop Olson's request, the woman and a man who organise the "Dry Bones Ministry" were scheduled to meet with the bishop, but the woman canceled, saying she would be available in the future and only with a canon lawyer in attendance.

Bishop Olson said in his letter to diocesan Catholics that he regrets "any scandal that these false claims of 'Mystical Rose – Our Lady of Argyle' have caused to the parishioners of St Mark Catholic Church, within the Diocese of Fort Worth, and beyond."

He asked local Catholics to "pray for the healing and conversion of all involved in these matters that have brought about discord and disunity where there should be peace and communion" and he urged diocesan priests to be "especially aware of anyone who seeks guidance because of this scandal and to provide compassionate spiritual counselling."

In early August, the Fort Worth diocese said claims that the bishop had authenticated local sightings and messages of Mary were "not true".

"These claims of apparitions and messages are not verified or endorsed by the church, and in no way are the claims true that the Mystical Rose is a ministry of the Diocese of Fort Worth or of St Mark (Parish)," said the diocese in a statement, adding: "Bishop Olson does not encourage anyone to offer credence or support for these claimed apparitions."

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99