03 October 2018, The Tablet

US confidence in Pope Francis falls amid sexual abuse scandal

Sixty-two percent of American Catholics believe Pope Francis is doing only a fair or poor job handling the abuse crisis

US confidence in Pope Francis falls amid sexual abuse scandal

Pope Francis loses his skull cap during the Sept. 26 general audience in St. Peter's Square at the Vatican.
Photo: CNS photo/Tony Gentile, Reuters

With Pope Francis halfway into the sixth year of his pontificate, the percentage of US Catholics who view him favourably, while still strong, is noticeably down.

And, compared to a January poll by the Pew Research Centre that showed Catholics being evenly split on how well Pope Francis has handled the issue of clergy sex abuse, numbers in the new poll, released 2 October, show that twice as many Catholics feel he is doing only a fair or poor job on the issue than say he is doing a good or excellent job.

The overall favourability number for the pope is 72 per cent, split between 42 per cent of Catholics who see him "mostly favourable" and 30 percent who view him "very favourable." The latter number down a third from the last Pew poll last January, when Pope Francis had been at 84 percent favourability. The 72 percent figure is lower than Pew's favourability findings for Pope Benedict XVI except for its first poll asking the question shortly after Pope Benedict assumed the papacy in 2005.

Pope Francis' lowest favourability numbers are among Catholic men, at 66 per cent, and Catholic Republicans or those who lean Republican, at 61 per cent. They are highest among Catholic Democrats or those who lean Democratic, at 83 per cent, and Catholic women, at 77 percent. The percentage of Catholics overall who view him unfavorably, though, more than doubled, from 9 per cent to 20 per cent.

"The new study also shows that US Catholics' views of Pope Francis are increasingly polarised along political lines," said the Pew report on its poll. "For instance, in 2014, there was virtually no difference in views of Pope Francis" between Democrats and Republicans, with the latter giving him a 90 percent favourable rating and Democrats giving him an 87 per cent mark.

The pope's favourability numbers also suffered among white evangelical Protestants, from 52 per cent in January to 32 per cent in September; white mainline Protestants, from 67 per cent to 48 per cent; and religiously unaffiliated adults, from 58 percent to 53 percent. Still, 51 percent of all Americans view him favourably.

Sixty-two percent of Catholics believe Pope Francis is doing only a fair or poor job handling the abuse crisis, compared to 46 per cent in January. Those who believe he is doing an excellent or good job shrunk from 45 per cent in January to 31 per cent in September.

The drop is most pronounced among men and Catholics ages 18-49, with both groups registering under 30 per cent in the latest poll who say he is doing a good or excellent job, although the numbers among those who attend Mass at least weekly nosedived from 71 per cent to 34 per cent.

In other areas of church life, Catholics gave Pope Francis higher marks, although those numbers also declined.

In terms of standing up for traditional morals, 56 per cent said the pope was doing an excellent or good job, down from 81 percent in the first Pew poll assessing Catholic opinion of Pope Francis in 2014, while those who say he is doing only a fair or poor job more than doubled from 15 percent to 36 percent.

When it comes to spreading the Catholic faith, Pope Francis dipped from 81 per cent in 2014 to 56 percent in September among those saying he is doing a good or excellent job, while those who say he is doing only fair or poor climbed from 14 per cent to 27 per cent.

On the issue of appointing new bishops and cardinals, Pope Francis dropped from 58 per cent in the "good/excellent" category in January to 43 per cent in that category in September, while those who say he is doing only a fair or poor job rose from 24 per cent to 39 per cent.

The poll was taken in the wake of allegations by Archbishop Carlo Maria Vigano, the former papal nuncio to the United States, that Pope Francis knew about restrictions having been placed on the ministry of then-Cardinal Theodore E. McCarrick over allegations of sexual misconduct yet did nothing about them. Archbishop Vigano has demanded that the pope resign in the wake of his charges.

The results were based on phone interviews conducted Sept. 18-24 of 1,754 Americans, including 336 Catholics. The margin of error for all poll respondents is 2.7 percentage points, and 6.2 percentage points for Catholics, while the margin of error is larger for subgroups within the Catholic sample, peaking at 10.2 percent for Catholics ages 18-49 and those who attend Mass at least weekly.

  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99