Features > Difficult dialogue

26 May 2016 | by James Roberts

Difficult dialogue


The Vatican’s man promoting Christian unity talks to James Roberts about the challenge of Muslim relations

Before going to Cambridge to meet Cardinal Kurt Koch – the man with the Christian unity brief at the Vatican – I was hoping that a few sparks would fly across the Fens, as we touched on some of the hottest topics in the Church.

This was the man who, speaking in Germany last November, six days after the Islamist attacks in Paris claimed 130 lives, described the so-called Islamic State as a “satanic terrorist organisation”. Earlier in 2015, before the Synod on the Family, amid calls for church reforms that took account of the realities of contemporary life, he recalled that at the time of the Third Reich, some “German Christians” adjusted their faith to the “reality” of a passing world view: National Socialism. There can be no “third realities” of the Revelation next to Holy Scripture and the magisterium, he said.

Given that the cardinal has expressed such strong opinions about events in Europe and comes from the centre of the continent – he was born in Emmen, in the Swiss canton of Lucerne, 66 years ago – I wondered what he thought about Pope Francis’ critique. The Argentinian pope has said that Europe is not creative, not welcoming to immigrants and like an old grandmother. Some other cardinals – Dominik Duka from the Czech Republic, for example – have said he simply doesn’t understand Europe.

“[Francis] is aware not only of the difficulties in Europe but also the opportunities,” said Koch. “But yes, it is another view. Pope Benedict is European and has thought a great deal about European issues. Pope Francis is from another continent, and sees the situation in Europe with other eyes. It’s a challenge for us, to see our own continent with other eyes.”


Subscribe to The Tablet from just £19.99 quarterly
3 options available

Share this story

Article List

Post a Comment

You can post as a subscriber user...

User Comments (1)

Comment by: Ishvara
Posted: 26/05/2016 19:44:27
"It is impossible to be Christian and anti-Semitic", said Cardinal Koch. It does not seem to be a throw-away affirmation. Historically, the Roman Church, the champion of Christianity, has been anti-Semitic. Its anti-Semitism is traceable to its founder, Paul of Tarsus who rejected all that was Jewish: the race, the Law of Moses, the Prophets, Yahweh, the Jewish Christians, James and Peter to name but a few. This later extended to anti-Islamism through the Crusades. What Europe is now experiencing is the final revenge for the Crusades in mass migration from the Middle East and the violent onslaught by the ISIl.
This might be politically incorrect to say about Koch. He seems sadly to lack an historical perspective in his thinking and in his role.

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign Up

Latest Issue
Digital/PDF Version

PDF version (iPad-friendly)

Previous Issues
Tablet Subscription

Manage my subcription here