02 September 2021, The Tablet

The Mass that divides

Traditional Latin Mass

The Mass that divides

A priest elevates the host during a traditional Latin Mass
Photo: CNS, Gregory A. Shemitz


To understand why Pope Francis felt he had to act to end the experiment of allowing the old form of the Roman Rite to continue, his biographer spoke to Catholics in an English market town whose parish life and worship has been devastated by a group of traditionalists

The half-hour Sunday morning 9.30 parish liturgy at the Church of the Most Holy Trinity in the south Herefordshire town of Ledbury is spoken and perfunctory, and the 25-odd parishioners leave briskly, just as the trad­itionalists start arriving. Their Missa Cantata is not until 11.30, but there are rehearsals and eucharistic devotion before the Tridentine liturgy begins. There have been sung High Masses with Communion on the tongue in this yellow-brick church since July 2020, notwithstanding Covid restrictions, attended by up to 40 people driving in from across three counties. The liturgies are followed by the Rosary, and bring-and-share packed lunches in the parish hall until well into Sunday afternoon.

Between the church and the car park, a late-middle-aged woman approaches with a broad smile: am I the one doing the article about what has happened here? As she begins to tell me what I’ve already heard many times by now, tears well in her eyes. “It’s just so awful,” is all she can manage as she chokes up. “It was such a lovely parish. It has all ­broken down now.”
For Ledbury’s parish priest, Fr Adrian Wiltshire, 71, the pandemic was an opportun­ity last year to give the pre-Vatican II liturgy pride of place. As a result, many in the parish community felt sidelined. Pope Francis’ July edict restricting and regulating the use of the Traditional Latin Mass (TLM) has meant that Fr Wiltshire is now celebrating liturgies using the 1962 Missal without the permission of his bishop, George Stack of Cardiff. And the parishioners have fresh hope they can get back their parish.

Get Instant Access

Continue Reading

Register for free to read this article in full

Subscribe for unlimited access

From just £30 quarterly

  Complete access to all Tablet website content including all premium content.
  The full weekly edition in print and digital including our 179 years archive.
  PDF version to view on iPad, iPhone or computer.

Already a subscriber? Login

User Comments (1)

Comment by: Posy
Posted: 04/09/2021 07:43:08
As a medieval historian, I find it very strange that the Tridentine Mass, imposed in the sixteenth century, is seen as somehow THE fundamental, original Mass. In England, it replaced the rich diversity of the various Uses of the dioceses, the one most commonly found being the Use of Sarum. I sometimes think there were not more martyrs for the Mass in England because it was no longer the Mass they had grown up with. If we were to go back to the origins of the Mass, should we not be celebrating in Aramaic or Greek?