Rumpole on speed
Chris Daw would be the brief of my choice if I was in a tight spot as a defendant in a fiercely contested criminal trial.
Justice on Trial: Radical Solutionsfor a System at Breaking Point
CHRIS DAW
(BLOOMSBURY CONTINUUM, 288 PP, £16.99)
Tblet bookshop price £15.29 • Tel 020 7799 4064
Chris Daw would be the brief of my choice if I was in a tight spot as a defendant in a fiercely contested criminal trial. He is a doughty fighter, a doggedly obsessive researcher, a colourful campaigner, a warm empathiser with the human frailties of sinners and a gifted raconteur who does not let the occasional exaggeration spoil a good argument. Part of him could be Rumpole on speed, but he is also a political homme sérieux with a determination to reform our disintegrating criminal justice system.
At first glance he seems to have launched himself on mission impossible. His three most passionate chapters are titled: “Why we should close all prisons”; “Why we should legalise drugs”; “Why children are never criminals”.
I am a supporter of reform in all three areas myself, but as I read these chapters there floated from the attic of my memory a comment made by Iain Macleod about Enoch Powell when they were both youthful acolytes of the Conservative Research Department in the 1950s: “I’m a fellow traveller with Enoch, but I like to get off one or two stops before the train crashes into the buffers at the terminus”. And yet… After reading Daw’s compelling 70 pages arguing for drug legalisation, I would give him my initially sceptical vote in the jury room. He marshals his evidence so thoroughly and persuasively that I found it hard to disagree with his conclusion: “We need a complete reversal of current policy, rolling back half a century of failed prohibition and moving to a legally licensed and regulated drug market.”
Get Instant Access
Continue Reading
Register for free to read this article in full
Subscribe for unlimited access
From just £37.50 quarterly
Print copy of The Tablet delivered directly to your door.
Complete access to all Tablet website content including all premium content.
Access to the weekly digital copy of The Tablet.
Full access to The Tablet’s archive – over 180 years of back issues.
Already a subscriber? Login
Help us keep The Tablet’s voice independent, clear and far-reaching.
Founded in 1840, The Tablet is the leading independent English-language Catholic weekly, celebrated for great writing, astute analysis, brilliant arts and books reviews and trustworthy reporting from correspondents in Britain, Ireland, Rome and across the world.
Independent, high-quality journalism is at the heart of what we do. The Tablet does not have deep pockets and we are not funded by rich donors. If you appreciate our work please consider supporting The Tablet’s Development Fund. It only takes a moment and you can cancel at any time.
- Support with £5 per month
- Support with £10 per month
- Support with other amount.
