News

Canadian Churches and NGOs take government to court over refugee pact with US

10 July 2017 | by Catholic News Service

At present, refugees at Canada's land border with the US are turned away and told they must apply for refugee status in the US

Canada's major churches, the Canadian Council for Refugees and Amnesty International Canada are taking the federal government to court, hoping to strike down a 13-year-old agreement between the United States and Canada on treatment of refugees.

The legal challenge to the Safe Third Country Agreement between Canada and the US contends that Canada cannot rely on the fairness or objectivity of the American system for granting or denying asylum to potential refugees. In force since 2004, the agreement forces refugees to claim asylum in the first safe country they arrive in. With a very few exceptions, refugees at Canada's land border with the US are turned away and told they must apply for refugee status in the US - they may not claim asylum in Canada.

"It is wrong, morally and legally, to send claimants back to the US knowing, as we do, that they may face serious violations of their basic rights," Loly Rico, president of the Canadian Council for Refugees and co-director of FCJ Hamilton House, said in a 5 July statement.

The Canadian Council of Churches - which includes the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops - Amnesty International and the Canadian Council for Refugees won a similar case against the Safe Third Country Agreement in Federal Court in 2008. That decision was overturned on appeal, not on the substance of the case but on a question of whether the organisations bringing the case to court had standing to make their legal argument against the agreement.

This time the case is being brought on behalf of a Salvadoran woman, identified only as "E," who fled through the United States with her daughters after a decade of being targeted by a drug gang threatening her with death. Her legal team claims she cannot get a fair hearing in the US, but she has good reason to believe she would be granted asylum in Canada.

"It is imperative that all who seek refuge in Canada are afforded the protections guaranteed to them under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and international human rights treaties," said the Rev. Karen Hamilton, Canadian Council of Churches general secretary.

Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada argues that safe third-country agreements are supported in principle by the UN High Commissioner for Refugees.

"Similar agreements are used by countries around the world to control pressures on asylum systems," IRCC spokeswoman Nancy Chan told The Catholic Register, a national Catholic weekly based in Toronto. "The STCA remains an important tool for Canada and the US to work together on the orderly handling of refugee claims made in our countries."

The agreement mandates that Canadian officials monitor US immigration courts to determine whether the U.S. system meets international standards under the UN's 1951 Refugee Convention.

The churches and refugee advocates claim US handling of refugees outside of its immigration courts is discriminatory, that the courts themselves are arbitrary, widespread use of detention is designed to deny refugees access to immigration courts and that conditions for refugees trying to make asylum claims in the United States have deteriorated significantly under the administration of President Donald Trump.

"The US was never safe for all refugees and now is even less safe," Rico said.

"Canada has carefully analyzed developments in the United States, including with respect to the recent executive orders related to immigration and refugee matters, and determined that the U.S. remains a safe country for asylum claimants to seek protection there," Chan wrote in an email. "This finding is also shared by the U.N. Refugee Agency (UNHCR)."

In May, the Canadian Council for Refugees and Amnesty International Canada submitted a 52-page brief to Immigration Minister Ahmed Hussen outlining their concerns over political interference and dysfunction in the US refugee system.

"We hoped that the government would be willing to take a serious look at the human rights violations occurring in the U.S.," Janet Dench, executive director of the Canadian Council for Refugees, told The Catholic Register in an email. "We gave the government a timeline to respond, and an extension to that timeline at their request. We held off releasing the report until after their response, which did not address the substance of our submissions."

PICTURE: A man who told police he was from Mauritania is taken into custody in February by Royal Canadian Mounted Police officers after walking across the US-Canada border into Quebec



Article List


TABLET WORLD…
Latest Issue

Digital/PDF Version

PDF version (iPad-friendly)

Previous Issues
Latest Tweet
Share Us
Tablet Subscription

Manage my subcription here

Manage
Newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign Up
Top