04 June 2015, The Tablet

University merger talks stall as Heythrop sinks into the red



The future of Heythrop College is under threat after newly filed accounts reveal the 400-year-old institution is in a precarious financial position while talks over a merger with St Mary’s University seem to have stalled.

Accounts posted last week by the college reveal a £166,000 deficit despite the Society of Jesus increasing their grant to Heythrop to £1.835 million - a 160 per cent rise from last year.

The Jesuits, who founded, run and subsidise the college, have pledged a further £1.6 million over the next two years.  

But the Chairman of Heythrop’s Governors, Jeremy Heap, writes that the funding from the Society of Jesus is “time limited” and the college needs to find a “more robust operating model.”

A spokeswoman for the Society of Jesus said this week: “the order have always supported Heythrop College and have no plans not to continue to support them.”

She added: “the order remains committed to Higher Education which may be through a merger or another form of collaboration with St Mary's."

Financial pressures are likely to increase on Heythrop next year as the college has decided not to recruit undergraduates for this September. Last year tuition fees (and education contracts) amounted to £3.241 million, a significant proportion of the college’s total income of £7.949 million.

The accounts show that without investment from the Society of Jesus or St Mary’s University, in Twickenham, South West London, Heythrop is not economically viable.

Discussions about a partnership between Heythrop and St Mary’s, a recently established Catholic university who installed Cardinal Vincent Nichols as their Chancellor last week, have been going on since last summer.

Both institutions had said last month they had hoped to get an “agreement in principle” about a merger by the “early summer” however this seems to have been pushed pack.

A spokesman for St Mary’s explained that the formal talks between the two institutions have not started although discussions with various stakeholders were ongoing. A spokesman for Heythrop repeated a statement issued last week saying that the governing body would meet at the end of June to review progress on discussions. St Mary’s governing body will meet on 2 July. 

Along with the subsidy the college pays a peppercorn rent to the Jesuits for use of their site in Kensington Square, in central London, which was purchased by the order from the Religious of the Assumption in 2009 for around £45 million. The society also provides staffing to the college in the form of Jesuit priests who are not paid a competitive salary: this includes the Principal of the college, Fr Michael Holman SJ.

A key question for Heythrop, the Jesuits and the negotiations with St Mary’s lies in the future of the Kensington site, valued at around £100 million, with the spokeswoman for the society saying a sale is “not out of the question.”

As a condition of the 2009 purchase, the Assumption sisters included a clawback clause that means they would be entitled to some of the proceeds of any sale that lead to the site no longer being used primarily for education or Catholic purposes.

If the Jesuits were to sell the site they would need the permission of the Holy See who would also be paid a percentage of the sale price of the property. That money would be used for charitable purposes. Canon Law requires the order to show that there is a case for selling the asset including “urgent necessity, evident advantage, piety, charity” or “another grave pastoral reason.” 

Heythrop employs around 90 staff and the latest governors body minutes show that a consultation has taken place in relation to arrangements that would be put in place should redundancies need to be made.


  Loading ...
Get Instant Access
Subscribe to The Tablet for just £7.99

Subscribe today to take advantage of our introductory offers and enjoy 30 days' access for just £7.99