Bishops and palaces

02 May 2014 | Comments: 1

It is, with the greatest respect, misleading for Edmund Adamus, (Letters, 19 April) to pretend that "whoever Pope Francis appoints as the next Bishop of Salford has no choice but to live [at Wardley Hall] according to the terms of the purchase during the 1930s".

My late father was one of a group of Catholic businessmen instumental in that purchase. Certainly, if that residence ceases to be the bishop's seat, certain restrictive covenants could be triggered, and the diocese may well suffer financially – although by now I imagine that there could be legal remedies. But that financial disadvantage is precisely the "choice" that has to be made if the bishop were to move elsewhere, in fulfilment of Vatican ll's exhortation that "priests and bishops … have the kind of residence which will appear closed to no one, and which no one will fear to visit , even the humblest", (Presbyterorum Ordinis, n17). He may well decide that for a bishop today to live in a "Tudor (formerly moated) mansion", falls foul of that requirement, as well as being an instance of what your own editorial identifies as "the worship of false gods, and neglect of the poor" and a contradiction of Prophet Pope Francis's own example and encouragement.

Towards the end of Vatican 11 the then Bishop of Salford, Thomas Holland, enlivened many a meal at the English College as he freely discussed with his brother-bishops and others precisely this question – should he move from Wardley Hall? He decided not to – but he had the choice, and so does the next bishop.

Basil Loftus, Sutherland

Latest Issue
Digital/PDF Version

PDF version (iPad-friendly)

Previous Issues
Latest Tweet
Most Read Articles

£100m Heythrop College put up for sale by Jesuits26 September 2016 by Sean Smith

Catholic development charity announces closure22 September 2016 by Megan Cornwell

Pope cracks down on cash payments in miracle approval process23 September 2016 by Christopher Lamb in Rome

At the hour of our deathPremium22 September 2016 by Jonathan Riley-Smith

A mind changedPremium22 September 2016 by Peter Stanford

Breaking down the wallPremium22 September 2016 by Jeroom Heyndrickx

Share Us
Tablet Subscription

Manage my subcription here


Sign up for our newsletter

Sign Up