Letters

Scots discord

04 April 2014

James MacMillan’s promise to use ‘robust tactics’, in his quest for a seat on the National Music Advisory Board (Notebook, 29 March) suggests he is neither pastor nor liturgist. No point, then, mentioning theology, ecclesiology or aesthetics as he seems content in the narrow world of ecclesiastical committee-politicking! Sadly this discredits any valid argument but worse, reduces the Sacred Liturgy. What is the “source and summit of our unity and peace” is become the battleground, not for meaning, but opinion and personality.

After the dreadful 12 months we have had in Scotland, and on the cusp of the closure and amalgamation of parishes in this archdiocese, it is ill-judged of MacMillan to be lobbing ideological hand grenades at already beleaguered and anxious communities. He wants to teach us about “prayer through song”; what does he judge we are trying to do every single day in our churches?
Fr Jim Lawlor, Glasgow



Article List


TABLET WORLD…
Latest Issue
Digital/PDF Version

PDF version (iPad-friendly)

Previous Issues
Latest Tweet
Most Read Articles

Pope 'deeply saddened' by Westminster terrorist attack and assures those affected of his prayers23 March 2017 by Rose Gamble

Meetings, money and dress code: how Francis is trying to change curia, by one of his most influential advisors21 March 2017 by Christopher Lamb

East Africa Food Crisis: Humanitarian aid is more than food. It is a sign of hope.22 March 2017 by Michael O’Riordan

Pope 'deeply saddened' by Westminster terrorist attack and assures those affected of his prayers23 March 2017 by Rose Gamble

Meetings, money and dress code: how Francis is trying to change curia, by one of his most influential advisors21 March 2017 by Christopher Lamb

East Africa Food Crisis: Humanitarian aid is more than food. It is a sign of hope.22 March 2017 by Michael O’Riordan

Eamonn Casey remembered: Charismatic, complex, champion of the poorPremium23 March 2017 by Sally O’Neill

Thinking out of the box: Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi says the church should offer discussion not ready-made answers Premium23 March 2017 by Christopher Lamb

We have lost the sense, strong in the early Church, that asceticism sets us freePremium23 March 2017 by Sara Maitland

Eamonn Casey remembered: Charismatic, complex, champion of the poorPremium23 March 2017 by Sally O’Neill

Thinking out of the box: Cardinal Gianfranco Ravasi says the church should offer discussion not ready-made answers Premium23 March 2017 by Christopher Lamb

We have lost the sense, strong in the early Church, that asceticism sets us freePremium23 March 2017 by Sara Maitland

Share Us
Tablet Subscription

Manage my subcription here

Manage
Newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter

Sign Up
Top