27 July 2016, The Tablet

Ways we’ll live now: should we respect the will of the people, and is there an alternative


History may provide some clues to how we learn to live after the referendum vote to leave the European Union

 

We must obey the will of the people ... at least for the moment. But should we respect it, any more than we respect other, self-defeating policies endorsed by majority opinions throughout history? And is there an alternative?

Some years ago I gave a lecture on the history of the small town in southern Poland from which my family hails. At the end a fellow historian in the audience got up and said, in a dismissive tone: “You sound as if you’re lamenting the fall of the Austro-Hungarian empire.” “Of course!” I replied. For all its faults, after all, the empire provided the peoples of east-central Europe with a reasonably decent way to live together, at any rate by comparison with what followed.

After 1918, the “successor states” plunged into ethnocentric squabbling and economic nationalism. Tariff wars, competitive currency devaluations and restrictions on migration, supposedly designed to combat the Great Depression, instead exacerbated its effects. The declared goals were national self-determination and popular sovereignty. Soon those were obliterated and replaced by police states and foreign occupation.

Get Instant Access

Continue Reading


Register for free to read this article in full


Subscribe for unlimited access

From just £30 quarterly

  Complete access to all Tablet website content including all premium content.
  The full weekly edition in print and digital including our 179 years archive.
  PDF version to view on iPad, iPhone or computer.

Already a subscriber? Login



User Comments (2)

Comment by: Pat
Posted: 01/08/2016 10:40:41
It's so amusing to see the so called educational and cultural "elite" betray their utter contempt for ordinary people when they don't get their way. The EU is an undemocratic behemoth that has moved far from being a set of trade agreements. It is now effectively a sinister attempt to socially engineer a socialist superstate by stealth. It is facilitated and enabled by people such as the professor here. What is it about democracy that allegedly intelligent people like this cannot understand? I'm heartily sick of people dredging up their own boring immigrant stories to justify a bizarre desire to destroy the country and culture that was good enough to take them in. Any pretence the EU had of being a democratic institution has long since died. As Catholics we should easily recognise the EU as being profoundly antagonistic to our faith. The way that Leave voters have been demonised and belittled is appalling and constitutes in every way a hate crime. 
I note that Professor Wasserstein is connected with the University of Chicago which gave a home to the Frankfurt School. The pernicious and anti_Christian evil propagated by that institution has done more to destroy the social and cultural fabric of Western society than any battalion of Soviet tanks ever did. The "intellectuals" who formed that socialist subversion group also conspired to overthrow the very democracy that gave them safe haven from Nazi Germany. Perhaps a little gratitude would have been more appropriate?
Comment by: Ed
Posted: 29/07/2016 15:01:58
No democracy, then. Or at least no direct democracy, such as in Switzerland. It is entertaining to see people endorse democracy but only when the unwashed vote the way required by those who know better. No, professor, no. The point of democracy is that your learned opinion doesn't matter more or less than the opinion of the fishmonger or the bricklayer.