19 October 2013, The Tablet

Glimpses of Eden


 
The plan seemed foolproof: one of us climb up and give the tree an almighty shake while the rest stand underneath with a sheet to catch the loosened fruit. This year, however, the boughs are so heavily laden that a single shake brought down a hail of apples, pelting heads and drumming shoulders. Easier just to pick through the windfalls, and keep the unbruised ones for storing. It’s national apple week, and time to harvest the orchard fruits. Is there a greater work of art than an apple freshly picked, especially if a single green leaf is still attached? The fragrance, the promise of flavour, the way it sits in the palm of your hand. Impossible not to take a bite. No wonder mythology often thrusts apples into the limelight. Adam and Eve receive the doubtful gift of knowledge by eat
Get Instant Access

Continue Reading


Register for free to read this article in full


Subscribe for unlimited access

From just £30 quarterly

  Complete access to all Tablet website content including all premium content.
  The full weekly edition in print and digital including our 179 years archive.
  PDF version to view on iPad, iPhone or computer.

Already a subscriber? Login



User Comments (2)

Comment by: C. Ames
Posted: 26/08/2015 00:04:12

Unfortunately, most people get their values from religion, and the concept of religion is inherently antithetical to animal dignity and is a device repeatedly used to harm and devalue them. Every time I hear the phrase "the sanctity of HUMAN life," I'm reminded of its corollary, "the INsanctity of nonhuman life." Every time I hear "each and every HUMAN life has absolute value," I'm reminded of its corollary, "and nonhuman life has ABSOLUTELY no value." Think of the murder of Cecil, the African lion. Are nonhuman animals TROPHIES? Are they "things" (as Jesuit priest and philosopher Joseph Rickaby called them ("brute beasts").

In “Catholic Exemplars: Recent Popes, Medieval Saints, and Animal Liberation,” Philosophy professor Judith Barad premises Aquinas as an “exemplar” because he concluded that animals and plants have souls, although they are not the same as human souls; he also acknowledge that animals have feelings. To counter such a depiction of Aquinas who helped embed speciesism more deeply into Catholicism than it had been before, Aquinas declared “by divine province that non-rational beings should serve the higher species.” Aquinas regarded animals as non-rational, an idea that in turn influenced centuries of Christian thought. FALSE!

Comment by: a mom of three
Posted: 16/04/2015 01:54:15

It is like my father always said: If their are abortions, what's a animal? How true! The 'key' to all these unneccessary experiments is simply MONEY. All these places know they are useless--it is greed and pride--promised money-- and they do not care. My father also said very intelligent college people lacked common sense when he was in college many years ago. God help us--the world is going crazy. That is why some of these experiments are done on ships far from land. They think they are smart. I wish the animals could do this on them and see how they would like the pain. Pray everyone.