Last month's visit of Pope Francis to Mexico, was a spectacular public relations victory for president Enrique Peña Nieto. However, the trip ended up being an enormous disappointment to human rights defenders and the socially committed minority of the country’s Catholic Church.
This is because of Francis’ failure to address one of the nation’s most flagrant human rights issues: more than 25,000 disappearances since 2007, according to the Mexican Government’s own data. Even though forced disappearances have been defined as a crime against humanity, the Argentinian pope was utterly silent on the issue.
Is it unfair to expect that a Pope coming from the nation that 'educated' the world about forced disappearances, not only would have the evident moral authority to speak on the issue, but would also be particularly sensitive to the theme, given his own history and experiences in the past?
Mass Grave Mexico
The forced disappearancee of 43 students from Ayotzinapa in September 2014, led the heroic priest working with migrants in the impoverished state of Oaxaca, Fr. Alejandro Solalinde, to comment that “the whole of Mexico is a clandestine mass grave”. That same year one person went missing every day on average, and this in a nation without a military dictatorship. Just one week before Francis stepped onto Mexican soil, the headline of the newspaper Excelsior stated that 201 mass graves have been discovered in the country since 2006. In a previous story, the paper had pointed out that the government has 120 agents working on the more than 25, 000 missing person cases. This might explain why Amnesty International remarked that “search efforts for missing people were generally ineffective”.
Human Rights Watch (HRW) has described the missing 43 students as “the worst human rights atrocity in recent memory”. The criminal investigation has, at best, been unprofessional and HRW claims that the government has “proved unable or unwilling to conduct a serious investigation”.
Dirty War
The “Dirty War” in Argentina (1976-1983) led to thousands of missing persons. According to Argentinian president General Jorge Rafael Videla, in a 1979 press conference, the government could not do anything confronted with such cases, since the persons were “not dead, nor alive, but disappeared”.
Critics of Pope Francis have long condemned him for what they perceive as his inaction as Jesuit provincial during the Dirty War. In the analysis of Nobel Laureate Adolfo Pérez Esquivel, the provincial did not back the military regime. Still, Pérez Esquivel believes that Bergoglio “lacked the courage to accompany our struggle for human rights in the most difficult moments”.
As a relatively young leader of the Argentine Jesuits – Jorge Mario Bergoglio was 40 years old in 1976 – it might have been somewhat difficult for him to be very vocal against the military regime. However, it is almost impossible to understand why a Latin-American pope, with a life wisdom of almost 80 years including his personal experience of the Dirty War in Argentina, does not have the courage to denounce, and transmit a desperate cry to heaven with respect to 25,000 disappeared human beings.
Disappearing words
The word "disappeared" did not cross the lips of the Pope while on Mexican soil. Pérez Esquivel’s assessment of the young Jesuit provincial’s cowardice during the Dirty War, makes the silence of Francis faced with the 25,000 disappeared, and their families, in Mexico even more troublesome to interpret in a kind manner.
Before the visit, representatives from the Mexican authorities expressed strong confidence that the Pope would not say anything that might have “unpleasant political consequences”. When it comes to the negative effects of savage capitalism on human beings in today’s world, it seems that Pope Francis does not shy away from using his podium to scold the situation. We are only left to speculate on the reasons behind his ‘blackout’ on the issue of disappearances.
For the evangelical part of the Mexican Catholic Church it must be difficult to face a tomorrow with ongoing disappearances with a Pope that, effectively, did not touch one of the most burning human dignity issues in a contemporary Latin-American democracy. The Virgin of Guadalupe is probably wiping away a tear due to the fact that the prophetic voice of Pope Francis was muted in Mexico.
KEEP UP TO DATE ON TWITTER AND FACEBOOK...
Follow all the latest news and events from the Catholic world via The Tablet's Twitter feed @the_tablet
Or you can join in the debate at our community page on Facebook
What do you think?
You can post as a subscriber user ...
User comments (18)
save your marriage if it is heading for divorce now, Hello everyone! Life without my lover was a real disaster for me,What on Earth will i do to thank Dr.Abele for his help. Are you having a hard time searching for a way to get your ex partner back, look no further, this was how i got mine back you can get yours today. My husband and I have been through every top reason for divorce; financial struggles, bankruptcy, stressful jobs, becoming parents when we weren’t ready (neither one of us would give our kids back just the amount of stress is overwhelming) we fought ALL the time over anything and everything. I threatened divorce all the time. One day after a fight I said I was done and filling. He told me he wasn’t in love with me anymore and he left me with our kinds. After a day or two of cooling off I realized that divorce is not what I wanted. No, our marriage was not healthy but we had so much going against us an neither one of us were trying. I begged for him to forgive me and that I didn’t mean it. He told me he loved me but wasn’t in love with me anymore. Those words hurt and I believed him.One day i was online for tutorials, as i was browsing i saw a review about a spell caster who a woman called vegadalyshe was testifying about a Dr called Abele how he solve her problem, i have heard about spell casting, and magic, i said okay i should give him a try i contacted the spell caster his name is D
I went in search of a solution for my problem when My husband wants to divorce me. we was married for 13 years and we have been through a lot, he has cheated on me before but I forgave him because I love him and moved on but later again he met a girl at work and thinks he is in love with her, so one day he told me he wants a divorce, for me I don't because I still loved him I know this must sound stupid but never wanted him go. I tried to make him see he is making a mistake but everything went wrong, I loved him so much but he refused to change his mind, i waited for him to come his senses but nothing worked so i had to contact a spell caster for help because i knew that will be the best solution, then i contacted manifestspellcast@yahoo.com to help me to unite i and my lover and finally i came to the spot of getting him back which was awesome, my husband came back home, It felt good to have my lover back, Manifest Spell has a real Magic, his spell is real!!!! Dr,Manifest is excellence..
Email: greatkekespelltemple@gmail.com
Website: http://greatkekespelltemple01.webs.com
Mobile Number: +1 386-336-9876
Mighty Dr Keke Has Done it again..My names are Sonya Weisner from USA. My ex split up with me 2 months ago and I have been trying to get him back since then. he left me with no contact and just ignores me constantly. I have pleaded and begged him through texts messages for him to come back to me but he wont reply, I wanted him back desperately. We where in a very good and sound relationship, I cry myself to sleep all the time yet he just ignores me and gets on with his life like I didn't exist with a New girlfriend, we where couple for o
I am Katherine from United Kingdom.am in very big problem in my Marriage when someone recommend me About Dr Love spell caster(drlovespellcastersolution@gmail.com or drlovessolution@yahoo.com tel:2348038096203).I got married last year in 23 April 2015 at the age of 27 to the man I loved and we were both living together happily A year after my mother-in-law and elder brother-in-law ruin my marriage.
My mother-in-law does black magic on my husband so that my husband wont listen me again.He always standwith his family.three months ago my husband request my hand in divorce.I tried my best to work things out with my husband but i think my best is not enough but I know he loves me but can't stand against his mother & brother. My father call my husband for patch up but all he wants is divorce with me.then i wrote Dr Love that he should help me bring back my husband into my life because I love my husband from the depth of my heart and he should listen to me and loves me again and after my message Dr Love request some information from me and i gave him All the details he requested,DR LOVE promise me evereything will be fine between 48 hours and my husband will be back to his senses and show me love like he use to do.truly a day after my husband wake me up with call to apologize for all his bad attitude to me and he regret of his action.i was very glad because Dr Love make me smile