Skip navigation

The Tablet

Last updated: 16 March 2010
Log in

Search

easter offer

Current issue


Previous issues


Archive


Further Reading

Liturgical Calendar


The Tablet Radio Show


Manage your Subscription


Newsletter

The Pastoral Review

Church in the World

Italy wants global ban on death penalty

Robert Mickens6 January 2007

The Italian Government this week formally petitioned the United Nations Security Council to initiate a process for an international moratorium on the death penalty, just days after Church and political leaders here resoundingly condemned the execution of the former Iraqi president, Saddam Hussein.

Italy, one of the rotating members of the Council, has already gained the support of Germany - which has just taken over the European Union presidency - and is looking for unanimous backing from all 27 EU members. Italy lobbied unsuccessfully for the moratorium in 1994 and 1999, when some 97 countries allowed the death penalty. Today it is legal in only 54 states - China, Saudi Arabia, Iran and the United States among them.

The Italian initiative for a worldwide ban on capital punishment was applauded by several church groups, most notably the Sant' Egidio Community, which has long been pushing for such a moratorium. The Vatican did not comment directly on Italy's UN campaign, but following the execution of Saddam Hussein on 30 December, it was unequivocal in its denunciation of the death penalty.

"A capital execution is always tragic news and a reason for sadness," said the director of the Holy See press office, Fr Federico Lombardi, the morning after the former Iraqi leader was put to death, adding "even when dealing with a person guilty of serious crimes".

The head of the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace, Cardinal Renato Martino, said the hanging was "an error, in the same way it was an error not to turn [Saddam's] trial over to the International Criminal Court". He insinuated that those responsible for killing the former Iraqi dictator were criminals. "The death penalty when it is not necessary is a crime, and in this case it was not necessary," he said, citing the Church's Catechism.

Archbishop Jean Sleiman OCD, head of Baghdad's Latin Rite Catholic community, told Vatican Radio (RV) that he worried that the execution would bring more violence. Another expert in the region, Professor Kaled Fouad Allam, told RV that he was concerned that the country's minority Sunni Muslims would be emboldened by Saddam's "martyrdom".

Italy's two major political coalitions, which remain bitterly divided over US/UK-led policy on Iraq, were united in opposition to Saddam's execution. Former Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi, who committed Italian troops to the "Coalition of the willing", joined rival and successor Romano Prodi in condemning the sentence. Mr Berlusconi said that hanging Saddam was an "historical mistake". Only one Italian party - the right-wing Northern League - applauded the execution.

The Italian Constitution forbids capital punishment and opinion polls continually indicate that the vast majority of Italians - most of whom are Catholics - support the ban. Pope Benedict XVI has made no direct comments on the execution, though he said recently that no one except God has the right to decide when someone's life should come to an end.

n Assyrian Christians have requested their own province in Iraq, following an invitation by Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshiyar Zebari. More than half of Iraq's Christians, many highly educated, have fled since 2003, says the Chaldean patriarchate of Baghdad. Wishing to reverse exodus, Mr Zebari said: "They are free to organise a province or regional government ... If they can do it in three provinces or even one it should and can be done."