ad1
Latest issue: 11 February 2012
Last updated: 10 February 2012

tpr

Church in the World

Priests’ hospital bioethics role under threat

Spain

Graham Keeley - 3 May 2008

MOVES BY Spain's recently re-elected socialist Government to bar priests from hospital bioethics committees have come under fire from one of the country's 10 cardinals, writes Graham Keeley.   

Archbishop of Madrid Cardinal Antonio Maria Rouco, who is also president of the Spanish bishops' conference, this week attacked an investigation by the country's attorney general into an agreement that allows Catholic priests to sit on ethics committees in hospitals in the capital city. It was signed 11 years ago by the bishops' conference and the conservative-run Madrid regional government.

Last week the national Government, which won a general election in March, ordered Attorney General Cándido Conde-Pumpido to see if the hospital accord violated patients' "right to personal intimacy, autonomy, health and religious liberty".

"The public health service cannot impose on patients based on religious beliefs," said Deputy Prime Minister Maria Teresa Fernandez de la Vega, adding legal action may follow if "fundamental" rights have been broken.

However, Cardinal Rouco dismissed the investigation as "an avalanche against fundamental values", adding that an absence of priests on hospital ethics committees would mean there would be no one to oppose measures such as abortion or euthanasia.

"Without priests there will be no one to stand against the culture of death," said the cardinal.

Juan José Güemes, of the Madrid regional government, said that in 1995 the socialist government of Prime Minister Felipe González sent a circular to the health authority in Madrid proposing that priests sit on hospital committees to debate matters such as bioethics. Two years later, under the right-wing Popular Party, the agreement was finalised to include priests on ethics and disciplinary committees in Madrid hospitals.

The current row comes weeks after Cardinal Rouco and Prime Minister José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero agreed to aim for warmer relations after a succession of rows over issues such as abortion and homosexuality during the socialists' previous administration.


Back to the front page

       

 In this week’s issue

When the hurt stops and the healing starts
Making markets moral
Iron and velvet
Love in a Catholic climate
Someone to talk to
A good Lent takes planning
South American surprise
Is the Church too slow in recognising that academies are the future for Catholic schools?
Christopher Lamb

Goodwin the scapegoat
Elena Curti

The pain of being a coeliac Catholic
Sr M, guest contributor

Why the Benedictine family will survive
Christopher Lamb

The Church's moral obligation to victims of clerical sexual abuse
Speeches from this week's conference in Rome

This week in Rome bishops and religious superiors met at the first Vatican-backed symposium devoted to forging a global response to the crisis of clerical sexual abuse that has disgraced ...


Archbishop voices 'shame and sorrow' after priest's abuse trial
Longley to visit parishes 'damaged' by Walsh

Today, Tuesday 7 February, Bede Walsh, who served as a Catholic priest in the Archdiocese of Birmingham, has been convicted by a jury, following a 10-day trial at Stoke-on-Trent ...

mobile
2011 lecture